Millennium Series Books II & III

Today’s post is a double-whammy review of two books I’ve been hooked on for the last couple of weeks – Stieg Larsson’s the The Girl Who Played with Fire and The Girl Who Kicked the Hornets’ Nest. I’ve squeezed them into one, because I think of the last two Millennium series books like a single story with an interval in between.  If you haven’t read the first book you might think that it’s not worth reading this review, but read on and you may be convinced to read all three!

I read The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo last year and really enjoyed it. While it is not a perfect novel for everyone, it has wide appeal, is a brilliant thriller, and is very well written one with particularly engaging characters. (See more of what I thought of the first one here.) It was the characters again that stood out for me in the final two books of the series which are quite different from the first in that the plot is almost exclusively focussed on the background of Lisbeth Salander, who is the tattooed anti-hero(ine) who we meet in the first book.

The Girl Who Played with Fire

Book II picks up a couple of years after the furore from the Wennerstrom Affair has died down.While Mikael Blomkvist is in Sweden still working at Millennium magazine, Lisbeth Salander has been travelling – escaping it seems from past events. On her return to Stockholm, she becomes mixed up in an investigation which two employees of Millennium Magazine, Dag and Mia are doing for a book on sex-trafficking. When the couple are murdered, Lisbeth goes on the run, suspected of the crime, and is portrayed in the papers as a ‘psychotic lesbian S&M satanist’.  As the story develops, a much deeper and more complex situation is revealed which is intimately connected with Lisbeth’s own personal history.

I had high expectations of this book as I had heard lots of comments that it was the best book of the series. It didn’t disappoint. Ever since the first book I’d been wanting to know more about Lisbeth and also wondering if her guardian Nils Bjurman would resurface, which he did along with a whole other set of new bile-inducing characters. Larsson creates a fascinating history for Salander which is revealed throughout the book, and helps the reader to make sense of her as a character. this is done effortlessly as part of the plot in which current events are a direct consequence of what has come before.

The Girl Who Played with Fire, had some brilliant plot twists and somehow managed to walk the line between having a selection of bizarre characters and making them seem almost realistic. In this book I found I could relate to Lisbeth much more. As a character she demands a sort of odd respect rather than being exactly likeable, and although I found I could empathise with her, I never felt that I was being manipulated into feeling sorry for her. She is portrayed as both a product of her background and also culpable for her own mistakes.

There’s alot of action in The Girl Who Played with Fire which makes for a taught and suspensful read right the way through.

My Rating:

8 out 10

The Girl that Kicked The Hornet’s Nest

Book III, follows on almost directly from where the previous book leaves off. Lisbeth is in hospital following recent events and yet again finds herself painted as a criminal with a long list of charges for which she will later be taken to court for. The story – a whopping 700-plus pages, mostly accounts for the time leading up to the trial in which Larsson answers the question – how on earth is she going to get out of this mess?! Lisbeth is the key to uncovering a scandal which is so secret that she finds herself with powerful enemies who are prepared to use any means necessary to keep her quiet.

Oddly enough, I liked The Girl Who Kicked the Hornets’ Nest even more than it’s predecessor. Most of the action takes place without Lisbeth as she is laid up in a secure wing of a hospital, but this is just as interesting. She becomes a sort of central figure, almost a totem. One group of characters (Mikael, Armansky) are investigating the past and fighting to clear her name, and another powerful, covert group of people are doing anything they can to discredit and harm her. Unusually for Lisbeth, she finds she has to rely on others to help her.

The Girl Who Kicked the Hornets’ Nes nicely finished up the trilogy for me. There is a strong moral theme to the series around the idea of consequence. The message seems to be that ‘the truth will out’, which may not always be the case in reality, but on a very fundamental level does speak to the idealist in me. Plus, it is delivered in such a violent and messy way that the sentiment wasn’t cloying or sweet.

My rating:

9 out of 10

Overview

The thing that makes the Millenium Trilogy both appealing to me and at some points a little bit of a conundrum is the depiction of strong women characters. At the end of The Girl Who Kicked the Hornets’ Nest, Blomkvist in reference to Lisbeth’s journey sums up neatly:

“When it comes down to it, this story is not primarily about spies and secret government agencies; it’s about violence against women, and the men who enable it.”

Larsson is quite ruthless in the way that he highlights the prevalence of misogyny in society through sex trafficking, stalking and on a common day to day level of women experiencing hatred in an office environment. He does this using an array of strong female characters that challenge typical female role models – notably Lisbeth herself – whose sexuality is ambiguous, is introverted yet has superior intelligence and is a technology geek. There is also Officer Figuerola – a spy of amazonian proportions, and Erica Berger – a tough career woman with an open marriage – amongst others. Larsson seems to be looking at the idea of femininity through a prism.

I’m sure that it isn’t a coincidence that like Mikael Blomkvist, Larsson was also a journalist. Many the female characters have sexual affairs with Blomkvist who seems to be strangely irresistible and at times I felt as if Larsson was living vicariously through this character. I’m sure it isn’t a coincidence that he was a journalist himself!

I had mixed feelings about the women characters. My gut tells me they are a little bit unbelievable – too perfect perhaps in their complexity and toughness. However, I also loved how tough, interesting and different they were. Larsson obviously had a healthy respect for women.

I so enjoyed the Millennium series and feel a little bereft now that I’ve finished it. I liked the fact that the investigative work is done by a roving reporter instead of the rather hackneyed archetype of a depressed male detective. While some of the female elements are little contrived, I can’t help but love the fact that Larsson cast women the key protagonists. Complex plotting, dark themes and compelling characters made this series really stand out for me. There is a reason why every other person on the tube has a copy of a Larsson book.

Have you read any of Stieg Larsson’s books or been put off by the hype?

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo by Stieg Larsson

A few days ago that I posted my excitement about starting to read Stieg Larsson’s The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo and now I’m going to tell you what I thought about it. In short, it was different from what I expected, but I definitely enjoyed reading it. After a little synopsis I will try to explain why.

Mikael Blomkvist, journalist and part-owner of left-wing magazine Millenium in Stockholm, has been taken to court over allegedly libellous accusations against the megalithic Wennerström Group. His career and the fate of his publication look to be in tatters, that is until he is head-hunted by Henrik Vanger to write the history of his family in return for a tidy sum and the chance to get back at Wennerström. However, when he takes on the job he finds himself in a complicated family drama involving Henrik’s niece Harriet, who went missing in the 1960’s. Lisbeth Salander (said girl with the tattoo), is a young woman with a penchant for nose-rings, slogan t-shirts and some serious personal-issues and is a researcher for a security firm. Lisbeth and Mikael’s paths cross as a result of the Vangar affair and they pair up to find-out the truth behind Harriet’s disappearance.

Why it wasn’t what I expected

• There was more scene-setting than I expected (i.e. it was a little slow at the beginning with lots of waffle about financial skull-duggery).
• It was grim, but less shocking than I thought it might be (maybe that’s just me).
• You don’t have to wait right until the end of the book to figure out what is going on.

Why I liked it

• Once I got through the initial scene-setting I quite liked the fact it was in-depth. When I’m enjoying a book it’s a good thing when it takes longer to read.
• I felt that the personalities in the book were interesting and pretty original and liked the fact that Mikael wasn’t your typical detective figure.
• I thought that there were several threads in the book – the case being investigated by Mikael, his conflict with Wennerström, and the back-story of Lisbeth who is a puzzle in herself – kept things fresh and added an extra layer of intrigue.
• It was a nice change of scene for me reading a murder story set in Sweden.
• I actually quite liked being able to figure out some of the plot myself, so I could mentally pat myself on the back.
• I felt as if there were still some mysteries unsolved at least about Lisbeth, and some things that might come back to haunt her so I am curious to read The Girl that Played with Fire.

Before reading The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo I made sure to try to distance myself from the hype of it, in the sense that I didn’t truly believe that it would be the most amazing thriller ever – which it wasn’t – but it was a very enjoyable (if you like grim murder plots). I always take the praise on book jackets with a pinch of salt anyway. While for me, The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo didn’t quite top Tom Rob Smith’s thriller-history hybrid, Child 44 or Sophie Hannah’s Little Face, I thought that it was very good indeed. It reminded me a little of Thomas Harris’s Red Dragon and Silence of the Lambs in the way that it is actually well-written as well as being gripping.

Read The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo if you fancy a new angle on the thriller genre and want to know what all the hype is about.

Have you read The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo?