Butterfield 8, by John O’Hara

4 stars4/5

BUtterfield 8, set in the 1930s, is the story of New York good time girl Gloria Wandrous who was inspired by real-life flapper-girl Starr Faithful. Don’t Google her if you plan to read the book! The story was also turned in to a film starring the late Elizabeth Taylor which is apparently only superficially based on the book but has already been added on my to-watch list.

Vintage Classics, 2008 paperback edition, 240 pages - book group choice

This is a novel that is definitely helped by discussion as I found out at my latest Riverside Readers group meeting. I can imagine it being an excellent book for a literature course, because there is so much depth to it. The strongest themes are around human relationships, particularly exploring love, sex, friendship and marriage. Gloria enjoys sexual freedom, hanging out in speakeasies, matching the men she meets drink for drink and yet she also has a great platonic friendship with Eddie “one of those plain Californians”, with whom we see her at her most vulnerable. O’Hara’s portrait of her seems honest, yet sympathetic. He seems to have a great understanding of, and respect for women which is expressed in the dialogue of his characters and makes me think that he must have had a great many close female friends.

Because of the liberal way in which women and men’s attitudes to sex are discussed BUtterfield 8 feels modern, but perhaps this is because in the early 1930’s, modernity was indeed clashing with the conservative elements in society.

A newspaper imaged pinched from the Starr Faithfull blog

One of the real strengths of this book is the way that O’Hara represents time and place. He really makes the reader feel the atmosphere, by using specific references whether it be the kind of cocktails that the characters drink, descriptions of the clothing that college-girls wear or of the “Yale boys”, “Mr. Average Man” or by refuting the idea that there can be any real “symbol of modern youth” as imagined by F. Scott Fitzgerald. O’Hara presents society in all its shades of grey. I also loved the way that O’Hara showed how the depression had only really begun to touch the upper echelons of society but gave practical examples of how it was effecting the professional classes such as increased rents. While the depression wasn’t central to the book it did add to the feeling that many people’s lives were ready to spiral out of their normal paths.

While many of the characters in the book are vivid, at times there were just too many of them for me! By the end of the book I was quite confused by who some of the people that meandered in and out of the plot. For me, this is where BUtterfield 8 loses points.

The gorgeous Elizabeth Taylor who played Starr Faithfull in the film of Butterfield 8, photographed by Richard Avedon as seen in Harper’s Bazaar, September 1960

Perhaps this is because O’Hara is trying to represent so many different aspects of society, but it does make for quite a confusing read. Having said that I think if I was to read it again in the future I would get much more from it and be able to piece the relationships together more easily. Again, this is why this book is fantastic for discussion as when I started to talk about it at my book-group I realised that I had actually absorbed a great amount of detail and though I couldn’t always remember who had said certain things, particular points made a strong impression on me.

Knowing now, what happens at the end of the book, I wonder if I would notice different characters much more, and yet I’m glad that I didn’t know the plot before because there is some excellent shock value in how the book culminates. BUtterfield 8 is a difficult book to score. It’s not actually difficult to read, but at times it was frustrating because there were so many strands to it. However, I do think it should be recognised as a true classic because of its originality, the impressive way in which O’Hara presents human relationships, his sympathetic and revealing characterisation of Gloria, and because it is really thought provoking. I actually scored it a 7 (3.5) at my book group, but I’ve made it up to 4/5 because the more I think about it the more I’m impressed by O’Hara’s skill as a writer and the vivid impression of this era that I’m left with. A warning though, BUtterfield 8 isn’t a long book but don’t try to read it in a rush and I would even say it’s worth keeping a notebook handy to remember the different characters and how they interlink. Thanks to Claire of Paperback Reader for the choice!

Interesting links (for if you don’t mind plot spoilers!)

  • A Time article about Starr Faithful here.
  • A blog devoted to the socialite here.

22 responses to “Butterfield 8, by John O’Hara

  1. What a fantastic cover!

    • Gorgeous isn’t it? I was going to look out for it in the library but then I thought I had to have a copy anyway!

  2. I think this is a shamefully under read and under rated book. I didn’t know anything about Starr Faithful so will be following up those links. It was the sympathy for Gloria – who could have been a really unsympathetic character – mixed with the seedy portrait of New York that made it a stand out read for me. I liked the way characters kept appearing and disappearing in little vignettes of city life.

    I’m also quite excited that vintage are releasing 2 more O’Hara’s.

  3. I’ve not read any O’Hara myself, but you have me interested. I’ve not seen the Elizabeth Taylor movie either–I thought it had been updated to the 1960’s. Both you and the wonderful new cover have me interested in BUtterfield 8 now. Do you think the character of Eddie was gay? From your description of him, it sounds like he might have been. I doubt Mr. O’Hara would have been able to openly portray him as such back when the book was written.

    • Hmm… well I did inwardly ask the question. It’s not obvious but it does seem possible because of the nature of the relationship between him and Gloria. I hope you enjoy it if you do get a copy!

  4. This was a really good book for discussion and really evoked the 1920s and 30s in America. Like you said, it was a very modern novel and quite shocking in parts. Great write-up Polly.

  5. I’m so glad I didn’t know about Star Faithful before I read this book, or it would have completely spoiled the ending! And I know it was kind of predictable about what happens to Gloria at the end, but I still felt it was really shocking. I actually gasped out loud when I read it!

    Great review, Polly!

  6. PS> I love that Times article… Their archive is brilliant, isn’t ? I recently discovered a great review of Ulysses on it dated 1934 which was wonderfully written and so down to earth. I particularly loved this line: “Is it dirty? To answer the man in the street in his own language, Yes.”

  7. Only saw the movie (wans’t it one of ET’s Oscars?) and it’s powerful stuff! Didn’t even know it was a book, actually. How’s O’Hara at presenting the POV of a woman?

    • Ooh, you make me want to watch it even more. O’Hara is AMAZING at presenting the female perspective. I was quite surprised actually at how insightful his writing was in this way.

  8. This is why I am so sad I am not part of the Riverside Readers anymore. Don’t tell anyone else but I am finding Book Groups a struggle here as they are a little, erm, pedestrian so far. Its very much modern and possibly by Richard and Judy or an award winner.

    That makes me sound snobby and horrid, and you know I am not, but books like this – which I have never heard of and might not – were just why I loved that Book Group so much!

    • Oh well I’m not going to complain that you like RR’s best 😛 It is rather a fabulous bunch of readers. Maybe you’ll have to skype in one time!

  9. Just added this one to my to-read list. I’m intrigued. Thanks for the review!

    • I think the short blurb on the back cover of the edition I picked up from the library today gave away what you so nicely avoided to give away in your review. Gah!

  10. This sounds excellent! For some reason, I had always thought this book was a about war…

    • 🙂 You must have been influenced by a cover or something? I had the opposite with Catch 22. I picked that up all interested and then discovered it was about war and put it down again…

  11. Pingback: BUtterfield 8 by John O’Hara « chasing bawa

  12. Pingback: May & June Review | Novel Insights

  13. After being bought up on a diet of F Scott Fitzgerald and P G Wodehouse to give me my view of 1930’s New York this was a revelation and a shock, but in a good way. Mae West pulls off a similar trick in ‘The Constant Sinner’ although Babe Gordon isn’t as sympathetic as Gloria, or for that matter as complex.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s