Never Let Me Go, by Kazuo Ishiguro

5 stars5/5

My latest book group at work gave me an  opportunity to choose a book  that had been on my to-read list for a while and one that I thought would be brilliant to talk about – Never Let Me Go, by Kazuo Ishiguro. Fortunately I wasn’t wrong about it being a good book for discussion.

Never Let Me Go

Faber & Faber, 2010 edition, paperback, 304 pages - book group choice

I had prepared by bringing the Faber reading guide along to yesterday’s meeting. It gave us a brilliant starting point, however it wasn’t long before we were having an animated discussion with a momentum all of it’s own!

The key characters in Never Let Me Go are Kathy, Ruth and Tommy who are all at school together in the idyllic-sounding Hailsham. It is told from the perspective of Kathy, who is now in her thirties. She looks back at her life and her memories of growing up with the other children at Hailsham school. The early pages of the novel are full of vivid descriptions of school-life, the relationships and day to day dramas that occur between pupils.

The first part of the novel is very detailed and the Kathy tells her story at her own pace. Slowly, Kathy drip-feeds the reader pieces of information that hint that something unsettling is going on under the surface. Some of the children at the school seem wary and fearful of the outside world, while others are emotionally disturbed.

I think that it is worth noting at this point that some members of the group found this pace a little frustrating at first. I’ve also heard people comment that they didn’t like the cold, detached style of the narrative voice, however I wasn’t put off by this and I liked that the language felt simple yet full of meaning.

An important part of the experience of Never Let Me Go is the way that the book creeps up on you so I really don’t want to go into too much detail about the plot. It is possible to guess, pretty early on what is going on, yet it is not until the end of the book that you really start to see the whole picture.

Kathy’s calm and sometimes disconnected voice ensures that for most of the novel the reader feels emotionally detached. The only character that I really felt any empathy for throughout the story was Tommy, though perhaps this is because Kathy herself feels connected to him as a character. Having said that, you do go on a very intimate journey with all three characters. I was actually quite surprised by how I felt at the end of the novel because it is not until the final pages that the impact of what Kathy is relating really hits the reader. Ishiguro ensures that the emotional impact of the book is most intense right at the end. It is as if he comes out and whacks you over the head – not with any real ‘twist’ exactly, but with a particular weight of feeling.

I’m so pleased that I discussed Never Let Me Go in a group, because even though I would have enjoyed reading it on my own anyway, the conversations within the group drew out all the different intricate layers of meaning and some of the more subtle nuances were highlighted that might otherwise have been missed.

Never Let Me Go affected me profoundly because of how beautifully constructed it was and how well the ideas were conveyed. The events of the novel felt a bit too possible, which made the story even more disturbing. It is an important book and one that I think is up there with some of the best dystopian novels such as Nineteen-Eighty-Four and Brave New World.

A must-read and absolutely worthy of being called a ‘modern classic’.

On a side note, I was really taken aback at how different the style of Never Let Me Go was to the only other Ishiguro novel that I’ve read, which was An Artist of a Floating World which I wasn’t a big fan of (maybe I’ll have to revisit). Have you read any  other Ishiguro novels that you would recommend?

For other book-groupers, a PDF guide with reading notes and questions from none other than the lovely Savidge Reads can be found here.

20 responses to “Never Let Me Go, by Kazuo Ishiguro

  1. I really must read this book, and soon! I have seen so many reviews of it recently (possibly because the film is out – which I also haven’t seen) and fortunately none of them have actually given away what happens, only just hint at something so I don’t feel it has been spoilt for me.

    Grear review, Polly 🙂

    • Thanks Bex! I want to see the movie now if only to scoff at how annoying Ms Knightly is although I’m secretly hoping she will be as brilliant as in Atonement. Do read it, it’s so worth it!

  2. I didn’t love this as much as Remains of the Day (which is one of my favourite books of all time) partly because I wasn’t all that surprised with the plot. I think I had read something similar so it wasn’t a big reveal for me. But what is interesting is the implication to our future society as I can just imagine it slowly happening. And it must have been a brilliant book group discussion. However, I am looking forward to watching the film!

  3. I’m with Sakura, Remains of the Day is one of my favourites of all time too! It’s so brooding. And then there is a brilliant film adaptation of that too, so you get to stretch out the joy for even longer.

  4. Ooooh I have the film on DVD (yes already) so maybe thats one to watch when we see each other next!!! I am so glad you loved it Polly as we might have fallen out forever if you hadn’t… and I am not even joking hahahahaha!

    Wonderful review, I wish I had thought of ‘drip fed’ and ‘weight of feeling’ when I was writing my review, and indeed my guide which you have very kindly linked to!

    • 🙂 thanks for those kind words, I’m glad you liked the review and can’t wait to see you (and the movie) with cuppa and maybe some popcorn!

  5. I’ve wondered about this one because it seems like I see the title a lot. Sounds like y’all had a great discussion. Thanks so much for sharing your review with us.

  6. This was my first read of the year and what a way to start 2011 off! Loved it. The twist wasn’t a surprise for me (I’d figured it out over the years) but it didn’t detract from my enjoyment of it at all and I was still caught up in the suspense.

    My only Ishiguro to date.

    • It doesn’t really turn into a big surprise does it especially as it’s sort of revealed slowly anyway. As you say thought – still suspensful!

  7. Oh dear, I’m one of those who really didn’t like this. I didn’t even dislike it that much, but I found the writing really, really bland… a big turn off for me. But I’m glad you enjoyed it, Polly!

  8. Oh I loved this book too, completely brilliant and haunting. It is definitely different in style from Remains of the Day and Artist of a Floating World, both of which I liked but not as much as Never Let Me Go. Enough to give anything else he’s written a try.

  9. Pingback: The Godless Boys, by Naomi Wood | Novel Insights

  10. Pingback: The Godless Boys, by Naomi Wood | Las Rias

  11. Pingback: What I’m Into This Month: September 2011 | WCV

  12. Pingback: Novel Insights’ Top 12 Books – 2011 | Novel Insights

  13. Pingback: First Resolution of the Year: Not Blogging! | Novel Insights

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s