A Room Swept White, by Sophie Hannah

3.5 stars3.5/5

A Room Swept White is the fifth book in Sophie Hannah’s crime novel series.

A Room Swept White, by Sophie Hannah

Hodder Paperbacks, 2010 edition (paperback), 480 pages - own purchase.

The central story revolves around a group of mothers whose children have died in uncertain circumstances. The mothers were convicted of killing their children and then later acquitted with the cause being put down to cot-death. Fliss Benson is asked to produce a documentary about the cases. She takes over from her boss Lawrence Natrass who is a zealous campaigner against what he believes are women who are victims of a miscarriage of justice. One day at work, Fliss receives an anonymous envelope. Inside it is a card with sixteen numbers laid out in four by four rows. She dismisses it as a prank until she later finds out that one of the mothers, Helen Yardley is found dead in her home. A card has been left on the body, just like the one Fliss received.

A Room Swept White is addictive. Like the other books, the story is told from the point of view of a female narrator – in this case Fliss – and through a series of interviews, articles and transcripts, as well as a more typical third-person retelling of the police investigation. I like this style because the story moves along at a fast pace and getting into the narrators head makes me feel more involved in the plot. Fliss is a bit neurotic which was a little irritating at times but also entertaining.

I thought that the cot death storyline risky but ultimately well implemented. Hannah uses the ambiguity surrounding the cases to full effect, causing the reader to constantly question whether the women were innocent victims of a miscarriage of justice or in some way culpable. A potentially sensitive subject, I think that Hannah quite cleverly explores the complexities in judging SIDS (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome) cases. She looks at how difficult it is for a jury with facts in a situation where medical opinion is not always conclusive and firm evidence is not available.

As usual, I loved the pithy writing style and it felt welcome to go back to characters that I was familiar with – Detective Simon Waterhouse, Sergeant Zailer and the rest. In A Room Swept White there was less focus on the relationship between Zailer and Waterhouse, which was ok because there was so much going on, but I miss this in the context of the series. I felt that the whole team was more involved in this book which I liked because it meant that I got to know more of the characters on the force.

There were a couple of little frustrations for me. The plot line involving the Chief Police Officer nicknamed “The Snowman” felt unfinished and the reveal wasn’t as much of a twist as in some of the other books in the series and felt over-complicated. However these are really small complaints about what was overall a cracking page-turner. I spent most of Sunday afternoon curled up and whizzed through the whole second half of the book (250 pages!). I’m just glad that I got myself a copy of Lasting Damage to read next, so I don’t have to go cold turkey…

My other Sophie Hannah reviews can be found here.

If you have read Sophie Hannah, are there other authors who have a similar style that you would recommend?

8 responses to “A Room Swept White, by Sophie Hannah

  1. I have only read Wrong Mother and I didn’t enjoy the execution of it, but this one intrigues me, I want to try her again.

    I can’t think of someone to recommend to you, but have you ever used this tool? http://bookseer.com/

  2. I’ve seen her books around but never read any. It sounds like I would like them, your review reminds me of Barry Maitland’s Brock and Kolla mysteries (which I love).
    Adding it to the wishlist!

  3. I worried when I read this one saw the cot death theme, but didn’t she handle it well? I picked up Lasting Damage at the library today, and it looks a little less issue driven but still very, very promising.

    As to recommendations, she’s a little less complex, but have you tried Jane Casey I wonder?

  4. I had just ordered one of Sophie Hannah’s books, so now I’m really looking forward to reading it this weekend. I was inspired by an interview between Sophie Hannah and Tana French, and would highly recommend Tana French for complex mysteries based on character.

  5. I prefered Lasting Damage to ARSW (although I did really enjoy this too). Looking forward to seeing what you think of the latest one, Polly.

    I agree with other comments about Jane Casey and Tana French – have you read any of theirs?

    • Totally agree with you that LD was better than ARSW! I haven’t read either Casey or French but looks like I’m going to have to 🙂

  6. Pingback: Lasting Damage, by Sophie Hannah | Novel Insights

  7. Pingback: Novel Insights’March Review | Novel Insights

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s